Wrestler of the Year
Winner: Chris Extreme Runner-Up: Teresa Quaranta
Most Loved of the Year
Winner: Travis Miller Runner-Up: Teresa Quaranta
Most Hated of the Year
Winner: Christ Carson Runner-Up: Stevie Swing
Newcomer of the Year
Winner: Lisa Seldon Runner-Up: Estelle Webb
Event of the Year
Winner: Broken Hearts Runner-Up: The Groundhog Day edition of Eternity
Upset of the Year
Winner: Travis Miller defeats Declan Turner for the World Title at the first event of 2011. Runner-Up: Stevie Swing manages to defeat the team of Travis Miller and Teresa Quaranta, on her own.
Moment of the Year
Winner: Chris Extreme defeats Chris Carson at Broken Hearts after stuffing him inside of a casket to end their lifetime rivalry and Carson's career. Afterwards, he goes nuts, sets it ablaze and begins chopping at it with an axe, with Blood for Blood playing in the background. Runner-Up: Travis Miller finally becomes World Champion after 7 years.
Shocker of the Year
Winner: Corey Page announces the closure of Sin Wrestling. Runner-Up: Nikita returns and wins the Ultraviolence Title at Over the Top Rope.
Champion of the Year
Winner: Lisa Seldon; Ultraviolence Title Runner-Up: Teresa Quaranta; Television Title
Worst Wrestler of the Year
NOTE: Before this award could be handed out, Jake Norton hijacked the presenters and stole the award for himself.
Comeback of the Year
Winner: Nikita Runner-Up: Shane Donovan and Destiny Daniels
Iron(wo)man of the Year
Winner: Teresa Quaranta Runner-Up: Lisa Seldon
Most Improved of 2011
Winner: Travis Miller Runner-Up: Estelle Webb
Finisher of the Year
Winner: Teresa Quaranta -- "Royal Butterfly" Runner-Up: Lisa Seldon -- "The Viledriver"
Feud of the Year
Winner: Chris Extreme vs. Christ Carson Runner-Up: Travis Miller vs. Stevie Swing and Horatio Q.
Babe of the Year
Winner: Stevie Swing Runner-Up: Nikita
Hunk of the Year
Winner: Chris Extreme Runner-Up: Travis Miller
Ouchies of the Year
Winner: The entire Auschwitz Prison Cage Match, complete with barbed-wire, electric currents, powerbombs from the top of the cage, etc. Runner-Up: Lisa Seldon delivers The Viledriver from the top rope to the floor -- onto mousetraps.
Match of the Year
Winner: Chris Extreme vs. Christ Carson; Auschwitz Prison Casket Match Runner-Up: Over the Top Rope Invitational Battle Royal
Hall of Fame Inductee
- Teresa Quaranta
Top 10 of the Year
01. Chris Extreme
02. Teresa Quaranta
03. Stevie Swing
04. Travis Miller
05. Jake Norton
